Utilizing Fish as Malaria Defenders Volume 60- Issue 3

Manfred Dakorah Asiedu¹*, Gideon Twieku² and Rhoda Diyie Lims³

• ¹CSIR-Biomedical and Public Health Research Unit, Ghana
• ²Biomedical and Public Health Research Unit, Ghana
• ³Fisheries and Aquaculture Division of the CSIR-Water Research Institute, Ghana

Received: January 25, 2024; Published: February 03, 2025

*Corresponding author: Manfred Dakorah Asiedu, CSIR-Biomedical and Public Health Research Unit Gideon Twieku , Rhoda Diyie Lims, Accra, Ghana

DOI: 10.26717/BJSTR.2025.60.009454

Abstract PDF

We propose to explore an eco-friendly and sustainable approach to malaria control by employing fish as biological agents to reduce mosquito populations. Given the rising challenges of insecticide resistance and the environmental concerns associated with chemical interventions, this project investigates the effectiveness of fish species in consuming mosquito larvae, thereby lowering the prevalence of malaria vectors. Through a combination of laboratory experiments, ecological assessments, and community engagement in malaria-endemic regions, the project will identify optimal fish species for this purpose, assess their impact on local ecosystems, and gauge community perspectives on adopting fish-based malaria control methods. Key objectives include evaluating predation efficiency, determining ecological compatibility, quantifying the reduction in malaria transmission, and fostering local involvement to enhance sustainability. This innovative approach has the potential to provide a scalable, environmentally conscious solution for malaria management, contributing to global public health efforts and advancing sustainable disease control strategies.

Keywords: Malaria Control; Biological Control Agents; Fish Predation; Mosquito Larvae Reduction; Eco- Friendly Approach; Disease Vector Management; Sustainable Malaria Control; Environmental Impact; Ecological Assessment; Predatory Fish; Insecticide Resistance; Public Health

Overview

The project aims to combat malaria transmission by introducing fish species that naturally feed on mosquito larvae into water sources where mosquitoes breed. These fish serve as “natural predators” of mosquito larvae, thus reducing the adult mosquito population and limiting the spread of malaria. This biological control method offers an eco-friendly, sustainable alternative to conventional insecticide- based malaria control methods, addressing issues like insecticide resistance and environmental impact.

Background

Malaria, caused by Plasmodium parasites and spread through the bites of Anopheles mosquitoes, remains a significant health and economic challenge, particularly in tropical and subtropical regions. Affecting nearly two billion people globally, malaria’s burden is profound, impacting public health systems, reducing workforce productivity, and hindering economic growth in endemic areas (Greenwood, et al. [1]). Historically, efforts to control malaria have relied on chemical solutions, including chloroquine treatments and the insecticide DDT, both of which were cornerstones of the World Health Organization’s 1955 Global Malaria Eradication Programme. However, resistance in both Plasmodium species to chloroquine and Anopheles mosquitoes to DDT ultimately hindered the program, leading to its abandonment in 1972 (Sahu, et al. [3,4]). Modern malaria control strategies emphasize integrated approaches targeting the mosquito population. While techniques such as Insecticide-Treated Bed Nets (ITNs) and Indoor Residual Spraying (IRS) target adult mosquitoes, these methods present drawbacks, including chemical resistance, environmental impacts, and high costs (Killeen, et al. [4]). This has led to renewed interest in larval control as a sustainable intervention strategy. Larval control, which targets mosquitoes at their most immobile life stage, offers potential advantages in areas where breeding sites are accessible and manageable (Walker, et al. [5,6]).

An emerging, eco-friendly approach involves using larvivorous, or mosquito-eating, fish species to reduce mosquito populations in breeding areas. These fish, which naturally prey on mosquito larvae, have shown promising results in reducing larval populations in various settings. Studies highlight successful malaria reduction in communities where larvivorous fish, such as Gambusia species, have been introduced, with malaria eradicated in select Indian villages following the introduction of these fish (Chandra, et al. [7,8]). Consequently, the deployment of larvivorous fish has gained traction in integrated malaria management strategies, particularly in regions with accessible water sources like rice paddies and ponds (Reiskind, et al. [9]). This approach requires an understanding of the dynamics among fish, mosquitoes, and humans to optimize its impact on malaria transmission. By combining elements of predator-prey models with epidemiological models, researchers have developed frameworks to explore how introducing larvivorous fish can alter malaria dynamics (Moore, et al. [10]). The promising results of these mathematical models suggest that, under the right conditions, introducing fish as biological defenders against mosquito larvae could effectively contribute to malaria control, reducing transmission rates and supporting other preventive measures (Lou, et al. [11,12]).

Malaria remains a major global health issue, particularly in tropical and subtropical regions where mosquitoes thrive. Traditional control methods, like insecticides, have faced challenges, including rising resistance in mosquito populations and environmental concerns regarding chemical use.

Need for Sustainable Solutions

Given the limitations of chemical interventions, the search for sustainable, non-chemical malaria control strategies has become increasingly important. Biological control methods that harness natural predator-prey relationships present a promising alternative.

Biological Control with Fish

Fish have been observed to naturally prey on mosquito larvae, and certain species are especially efficient in this regard. By introducing specific types of fish into mosquito-prone water sources, researchers can potentially reduce the number of mosquitoes, thereby lowering malaria transmission rates without harming the ecosystem.

Project Goals

This study seeks to identify and test the most effective fish species for mosquito control, evaluate the ecological impact of introducing these species into malaria-endemic regions, and engage with local communities to ensure sustainable and culturally accepted implementation.

Objectives

The primary objectives of this research are to: 1. Identify five fish species in Ghana with documented larvivorous properties through a comprehensive literature review.
2. Assess the predation efficiency of these identified fish species on malaria vector larvae.
3. Determine the most effective fish species for sustainable mosquito control in local environments
4. Evaluate the ecological impacts of introducing larvivorous fish into malaria- endemic water bodies.
5. Explore community perspectives and acceptance regarding the use of fish as a biological control strategy for malaria.
6. Quantify the potential reduction in malaria transmission achieved through fish predation on mosquito larvae.

The implementation of the proposal, “Utilizing Fish as Malaria Defenders,” involves several stages combining laboratory research, fieldwork, community engagement, and ecological assessment to establish fish-based biological control of malaria vectors. Here is the step-by-step approach to implementation

Study Design and Preparation

Species Selection: Identify fish species known for feeding on mosquito larvae. Five species are selected for this project: Gambusia affinis, Poecilia reticulata, Oreochromis niloticus, Oreochromis mossambicus, and Anabas testudineus.

Fish Sourcing: Obtain fish from the Fisheries and Aquaculture Division of the CSIR-Water Research Institute to ensure quality and consistency for laboratory and field experiments.

Laboratory Experiments

• Predation Rate Assessment: Conduct experiments to measure how effectively each fish species preys on mosquito larvae. Stockfish tanks with five individuals of each species and introduce 200 mosquito larvae into each tank. Monitor and measure larval consumption over 24-hour cycles using the larval dipping technique, which tracks how many larvae remain.

• Gut Content Analysis: At the end of each 24-hour cycle, one fish from each species is dissected, and PCR (Polymerase Chain Reaction) testing on the fish’s gut content is performed to detect mosquito DNA. This analysis confirms that mosquito larvae are being consumed and provides a quantifiable measure of predation.

Field Testing in Malaria-Endemic Regions

• Site Selection: Choose suitable water sources within malaria- endemic areas, such as ponds, cisterns, and household water storage facilities where mosquitoes commonly breed. Before stocking fish, perform larval dipping at each site to assess mosquito larvae density.

• Introduction of Fish: Stock selected water bodies with the most effective predatory fish species based on laboratory findings.

• Field Monitoring: Conduct daily larval dipping at each site to track mosquito larval reduction. Dissect one fish per day for gut content PCR analysis to verify continued consumption of mosquito larvae.

Community Involvement

• Consent and Collaboration: Engage with local communities to obtain consent, especially in household settings, and explain the purpose and methods of the project. Educate community members on how the fish will help reduce malaria transmission and empower them to participate in monitoring efforts.

• Workshops and Outreach: Conduct workshops to share the project’s goals, methods, and expected benefits, fostering community understanding and ownership.

Environmental and Ecological Assessments

• Ecological Monitoring: Observe the broader ecological impacts of introducing fish to local water sources to ensure that the intervention does not negatively affect non-target species or disrupt existing ecosystems. Use adaptive management strategies to mitigate any unforeseen ecological impacts.

• Species Compatibility: Prioritize native or ecologically compatible fish species to minimize the risk of disrupting local biodiversity.

Data Collection and Analysis

• Quantitative Analysis: Collect data on mosquito larvae population reduction and document any corresponding decrease in malaria incidence. Track fish predation rates and ecological impacts to evaluate the effectiveness and sustainability of the intervention.

• Community Feedback: Regularly gather community feedback to understand their perspectives and any concerns about the project’s impact on their environment.

Documentation and Reporting

• Progress Reports: Keep detailed records of field and laboratory observations, community feedback, and environmental data. Provide regular updates to stakeholders and funders to document successes, challenges, and learnings.

• Knowledge Dissemination: Share findings through presentations, publications, and collaborations with other malaria control organizations and public health stakeholders.

Impact

The proposal, “Utilizing Fish as Malaria Defenders,” could have significant impacts across several key areas, making it a promising addition to current malaria control strategies. Here are the primary anticipated impacts

Reduction in Malaria Transmission: By introducing predatory fish that consume mosquito larvae, the project directly targets the mosquito population at its source. This reduction in mosquito numbers could decrease malaria transmission rates in affected communities, contributing to overall public health improvements.

Eco-Friendly Disease Control: Unlike insecticides, which can lead to environmental pollution and resistance in mosquito populations, this biological control method minimizes chemical use. The project leverages natural ecosystem dynamics, promoting a sustainable, chemical-free approach to disease management that is less disruptive to local flora and fauna.

Increased Community Engagement and Ownership: By involving community members in monitoring and data collection, the project fosters local ownership and understanding of disease control methods. Educational programs and community workshops can increase awareness, empower communities, and improve long-term acceptance and maintenance of these fish-based interventions.

Support for Gender Equality: The project emphasizes inclusive involvement, encouraging both men and women to participate in decision- making and project implementation. Gender-sensitive training and roles in the project could help break down barriers and empower women, fostering more equitable access to resources and leadership opportunities within the community.

Identification of Optimal Species for Mosquito Control: By evaluating the predation rates of different fish species on mosquito larvae, the study can identify the most effective species for reducing mosquito populations. This data will be valuable for future malaria control initiatives, potentially guiding the selection of fish species best suited to various ecological settings.

Positive Environmental Impact and Biodiversity Preservation: The project carefully considers environmental compatibility by choosing fish species with minimal disruption to local ecosystems. Using native or low-impact species reduces the risk of invasive species introduction, protecting biodiversity and maintaining ecological balance in malaria- endemic water bodies.

Innovation in Malaria Research and Control: This proposal adds to the body of malaria research by exploring novel biological methods, expanding the toolkit of malaria control strategies. Its success could pave the way for more nature-based solutions in disease control, potentially inspiring other research initiatives focused on leveraging natural predators in public health efforts.

Council for Scientific and Industrial Research - Biomedical and Public Health Research Unit

Ethics and Security

Ethical Approach: Engaging local communities is essential. The project requires informed consent from households and community members in malaria-endemic areas, especially where fish are introduced to water sources near homes.

Implementation: Educate community members on the purpose, benefits, and methods of the project to foster transparency and trust. Collaborate with community leaders to address local concerns and integrate traditional knowledge.

Security Concern: Introducing fish into ecosystems could inadvertently harm local species or create imbalances if not properly managed.

Mitigation: The project emphasizes using native or non-invasive fish species, and ecological assessments will be conducted throughout to monitor any potential negative impacts on biodiversity.

The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

1. Greenwood BM, Bojang K, Whitty CJ, Targett GA (2005) Malaria. The Lancet 365 (9469): 1487‑
2. Sahu M, Tediosi F, Noor AM, Aponte JJ, Fink G (2020) Health systems and global progress towards malaria elimination, 2000-2016. Malaria journal 19(1): 141.
3. Singh N, Nagpal AC, Saxena A, Singh MP (2004) Changing scenario of malaria in central India, the replacement of Plasmodium vivax by Plasmodium falciparum (1986–2000). Trop Med Int Health 9(3): 364-371.
4. Killeen GF, Fillinger U, Knols BG (2002) Advantages of larval control for African malaria vectors: Low mobility and behavioural responsiveness of immature mosquito stages allow high effective coverage. Malaria Journal 1(1): 8.
5. Walker K, Lynch M (2007) Contributions of Anopheles larval control to malaria suppression in tropical Africa: review of achievements and potential. Medical and Veterinary Entomology 21(1): 2‑
6. Snow R, Guerra C, Noor A, Myint H, Hay S (2005) The global distribution of clinical episodes of Plasmodium falciparum malaria. Nature 434(7030): 214‑
7. Chandra G, Bhattacharjee I, Chatterjee SN, Ghosh A (2008) Mosquito control by larvivorous fish. The Indian journal of medical research 127(1): 13‑
8. Ghosh SK, Dash AP (2007) Larvivorous fish against malaria vectors: a new outlook. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 101(11): 1063‑
9. Reiskind MH, Lounibos LP (2009) Effects of intraspecific larval competition on adult longevity in the mosquitoes Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus. Medical and Veterinary Entomology 23(1): 62‑
10. Moore S, Borer E, Hosseini P (2009) Predators indirectly control vector-borne disease: linking predator–prey and host–pathogen models. Journal of The Royal Society Interface 7(42): 161‑
11. Lou Y, Zhao X (2011) Modelling Malaria Control by Introduction of Larvivorous Fish. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 73(10): 2384‑
12. Oliveira N, Hilker F (2009) Modelling Disease Introduction as Biological Control of Invasive Predators to Preserve Endangered Prey. Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 72(2): 444‑