Radiation Therapy (RT) Target Volume Determination
for Locally Advanced Pyriform Sinus Carcinoma:
An Original Research Article Revisiting the Role of
Multimodality Imaging Volume 45- Issue 1
Omer Sager*, Selcuk Demiral, Ferrat Dincoglan and Murat Beyzadeoglu
Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Health Sciences, Gulhane Medical Faculty, Turkey
Received: July 04, 2022; Published: July 13, 2022
*Corresponding author: Omer SAGER, University of Health Sciences, Gulhane Medical Faculty, Department of Radiation
Oncology, Gn.Tevfik Saglam Cad. 06018, Etlik, Kecioren Ankara, Turkey
Objective: The hypopharynx is a critical region of the head and neck including
three primary anatomical subsites, namely the pyriform sinuses, the posterior
pharyngeal wall, and the postcricoid area. Although comprising a relatively smaller
proportion among all cancers, pyriform sinus carcinomas account for the majority of
hypopharyngeal tumors. Radiation therapy (RT) plays a critical role for management
of pyriform sinus carcinomas with encouraging therapeutic outcomes. Optimal target
volume definition has been a more critical component of current RT protocols for
pyriform sinus tumors. In this original research article, we shed light on this critical
issue by assessment of of multimodality imaging with incorporation of Magnetic
Resonance Imaging (MRI) for RT target volume determination of locally advanced
pyriform sinus carcinomas.
Materials and Methods: We have performed a comparative analysis of target
volume definition for radiotherapeutic management of locally advanced pyriform
sinus carcinomas based on Computed Tomography (CT) simulation images only or by
incorporation of fused CT-MRI. Primary objective of the study was to assess the role
of multimodality imaging for target volume determination along with other factors
including critical organ delineation, interobserver and intraobserver variations.
Results: As the primary result, the ground truth target volume was found to be
identical with fused CT-MRI based delineation for patients with locally advanced
pyriform sinus carcinoma.
Conclusion: Multimodality imaging with incorporation of MRI in the RT planning
procedure may be considered for patients with locally advanced pyriform sinus
carcinomas.
Abbreviations:: RT: Radiation Therapy;
MRI: Magnetic Resonance Imaging;
IGRT: Image Guided RT; ART: Adaptive
RT; CT: Computed Tomography; AAPM:
American Association of Physicists
in Medicine; ICRU: International
Commission on Radiation Units and
Measurements
The hypopharynx is a critical region of the head and neck
including three primary anatomical subsites, namely the pyriform
sinuses, the posterior pharyngeal wall, and the postcricoid area
[1]. Although comprising a relatively smaller proportion among
all cancers, pyriform sinus carcinomas account for the majority of
hypopharyngeal tumors [2,3]. The hypopharyngeal region extends
from superior border of epiglottis and the pharyngoepiglottic folds
from the level of the hyoid bone above to the lower border of the
cricoid cartilage bellow [1]. This critical part of the head and neck
region is associated with critical body functions. Pyriform sinus
carcinomas may differ from other head and neck cancers with
their frequent presentation at relatively more advanced stages
due to substantial tumor growth before onset of symptoms [4].
Patients with alcohol abuse history and medical comorbidities
related to alcohol are more commonly diagnosed with pyriform
sinus carcinomas [4]. These tumors have tendency for lymphatic
and systemic spread which make the prognosis relatively poorer.
Also, the critical localization of these tumors in intimate association
with the hypopharynx and larynx poses an important concern
for surgical management. Removal of the entire larynx may be
required for surgical therapy which may lead to speech disruption.
Radiation therapy (RT) plays a critical role for management of
pyriform sinus carcinomas with encouraging therapeutic outcomes
[4-9]. Improvements in surgical management strategies, RT, and
systemic treatments have been reflected in longer life expectancy
for patients with pyriform sinus carcinomas.
In this respect, adverse effects of treatment have been
considered as a more important aspect of management in recent
years. Indeed, radiotherapeutic strategies have evolved in the
millenium era with introduction of sophisticated treatment
techniques including Intensity Modulated RT (IMRT), Image Guided
RT (IGRT), molecular imaging methods, automatic segmentation
techniques, stereotactic RT, and adaptive RT (ART) [10-48]. These
relatively never radiotherapeutic concepts have resulted in more
precise and accurate targeting of tumors along with steeper dose
gradients around the target volume for reduced normal tissue
exposure. Decreased critical organ doses may allow for reduced
treatment induced toxicity and target dose escalation which may
lead to achieving an improved therapeutic ratio. Clearly, vigilance
is required for implementation of these contemporary therapeutic
approaches in clinical practice. Optimal target volume definition
has been a more critical component of current RT protocols for
pyriform sinus tumors. In the meantime, Computed Tomography
(CT) simulation constitutes the backbone of RT planning in majority
of cancer centers universally. CT may be considered as a feasible
technique for dose calculation purposes, however, integration
of additional imaging modalities for RT planning may improve
accuracy and precision in target volume determination. Several
studies have addressed the utility of multimodality imaging for
improved target definition [49-84]. In this original research article,
we shed light on this critical issue by assessment of of multimodality
imaging with incorporation of Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)
for RT target volume determination of locally advanced pyriform
sinus carcinomas.
For many years, Department of Radiation Oncology at Gulhane
Medical Faculty, University of Health Sciences has been serving
as a tertiary cancer center of a referral institution for treatment
of several indications. In the context of this study, we have
performed a comparative analysis of target volume definition for
radiotherapeutic management of locally advanced pyriform sinus
carcinomas based on CT simulation images only or by incorporation
of fused CT-MRI. Primary objective of the study was to assess the
role of multimodality imaging for target volume determination
along with other factors including critical organ delineation,
interobserver and intraobserver variations. To be utilized for actual
treatment and for comparison purposes, we have generated a
ground target volume by the collaborative effort of board-certified
radiation oncologists after meticulous consideration of all imaging
and relevant data with colleague peer review and consensus.
Radiotherapeutic management of patients has been decided
following detailed individualized assessment by a multidisciplinary
group of experts from relevant disciplines including surgical
oncology and medical oncology. Specifically, patient, disease, and
treatment characteristics have been evaluated on an individual
basis by taking into account the age, symptomatology, performance
status, previous therapies, lesion size, location and association
with surrounding critical structures, contemplated outcomes of
suggested therapies, patient preferences and logistical issues.
Treatment delivery has been achieved by use of Synergy (Elekta,
UK) linear accelerator (LINAC) with integration of IGRT techniques.
CT simulation was performed by robust immobilization of the
patients. After acquisition of high-quality RT planning images at the
CT simulator (GE Lightspeed RT, GE Healthcare, Chalfont St. Giles,
UK), we have transferred the acquired RT planning images to the
delineation workstation (SimMD, GE, UK) through the network for
generation of individualized structure sets including the treatment
volumes and critical structures. A comparative analysis has been
conducted to assess target and critical organ definitions by use of
either CT simulation images only or by fused CT-MRI.
In this original research article, multimodality imaging for
target volume definition was assessed in patients referred for
radiotherapeutic management of locally advanced pyriform sinus
carcinoma at Department of Radiation Oncology, Gulhane Medical
Faculty, University of Health Sciences. To evaluate the impact of
multimodality imaging, we performed a comparative analysis
of target and critical organ determination by utilization of either
CT only imaging or by fused CT-MRI. Assessed tumor related
parameters included the lesion size, location and association with
surrounding normal tissues. As another aspect of management,
we also considered individual patient symptomatology, age,
performance status and logistical factors. Reports by American
Association of Physicists in Medicine (AAPM) and International
Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (ICRU) have
been taken into account in RT planning. RT plans have been
generated by considerable input from expert radiation physicists
with strict adherence to relevant guidelines. Electron density, tissue
heterogeneity, CT number and HU values in CT images have also
been considered. Primary objctive of RT planning was to achieve
optimal target coverage with minimal exposure of surrounding
normal tissues. The ground truth target volumes have been
vigilantly defined by the expert radiation oncologists after thorough
evaluation, rigorous colleague peer review process, and consensus
to be used for actual treatment and for comparison purposes.
Also, IGRT techniques were utilized for setup verification. Precise
delivery of irradiation was achieved by use of Synergy (Elekta,
UK) LINAC available at our department. As the primary result, the
ground truth target volume was found to be identical with fused CTMRI
based delineation for patients with locally advanced pyriform
sinus carcinoma.
Hypopharyngeal region constitutes an important component
of the head and neck site and contains three primary anatomical
subsites, namely the pyriform sinuses, the posterior pharyngeal
wall, and the postcricoid area [1]. While pyriform sinus carcinomas
comprise a relatively smaller proportion of all cancers, they
account for the majority of hypopharyngeal tumors [2,3]. The
hypopharyngeal region extending from superior border of epiglottis
and the pharyngoepiglottic folds from the level of the hyoid bone
above to the lower border of the cricoid cartilage bellow is a critical
subsite associated with critical body functions. Pyriform sinus
carcinomas may differ from the other head and neck carcinomas
due to more common presentation at relatively advanced disease
stages and significant tumor growth before onset of symptoms [4].
History of alcohol abuse and medical comorbidities associated with
alcohol may be present in patients diagnosed with pyriform sinus
carcinomas [4]. These tumors may have predilection for lymphatic
and systemic spread with a relatively bad prognosis. Additionally,
critical location of these tumors in close neighbourhood of the
hypopharynx and larynx comprises a challenge for optimal surgical
management. Complete surgical removal of the entire larynx might
be needed which could consequently result in speech disruption.
RT plays an eminent role in the management of pyriform sinus
carcinomas, and treatment results are promising [4-9].
Advances in surgery, RT, and systemic treatments have led to
longer life expectancy for patients with pyriform sinus carcinomas.
With this regard, treatment induced toxicity may be considered
as a critical aspect of contemporary management strategies.
Admittedly, irradiation approaches evolved in the millenium era
with introduction of contemporary treatment techniques such as
IMRT, IGRT, molecular imaging methods, automatic segmentation
techniques, stereotactic RT, ART [10-48]. State of the art RT concepts
have allowed for more precise targeting of tumors accompanied by
steep dose gradients around target volumes resulting in decreased
exposure of normal tissues. Reduction in critical organ doses
may improve the toxicity profile of radiation delivery, and also
treatment dose escalation strategies may be considered for further
improvements in treatment results. At this critical point, vigilance
is warranted for integration of these sophisticated treatment
strategies in clinical routine. Hereby, optimization of target volume
definition became a very important aspect of recent irradiation
protocols for pyriform sinus tumors. Currently, CT simulation
remains to be the more commonly utilized procedure for RT
planning purposes in a considerable proportion of cancer centers
on a global scale. CT should be regarded as a reasonable technique
for RT dose calculation purposes. Nevertheless, incorporation
of other imaging modalities for improved RT planning may be
considered. In the literature, many studies assessed the use of
multimodality imaging [49-85]. Our study may add to the growing
body of evidence supporting the utility of multimodality imaging
for improved target definition. In conclusion, multimodality
imaging with incorporation of MRI in the RT planning procedure
may be considered for patients with locally advanced pyriform
sinus carcinomas.
Demiral S, Dincoglan F, Sager O, Beyzadeoglu M (2021) Assessment of Multimodality Imaging for Target Definition of Intracranial Chondrosarcomas. Canc Therapy Oncol Int J 18: 001-005.
Sager O, Dincoglan F, Demiral S, Beyzadeoglu M (2019) Evaluation of Radiosurgery Target Volume Determination for Meningiomas Based on Computed Tomography (CT) And Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI). Cancer Sci Res Open Access 5: 1-4.