info@biomedres.us   +1 (720) 414-3554
  One Westbrook Corporate Center, Suite 300, Westchester, IL 60154, USA

Biomedical Journal of Scientific & Technical Research

January, 2020, Volume 24, 5, pp 18535-18547

Review Article

Review Article

Molybdenum as an Essential Element for Crops: An Overview

Muhammad Shoaib Rana1,2, Parashuram Bhantana1,2, Xue-cheng Sun1,2, Muhammad Imran1,2 Muhammad Shaaban3, Mohamed G. Moussa1,2, Muhammad Hamzah Saleem4, Ali Mohamed Elyamine1,2, Rana Binyamin5, Mufid Alam6, Javaria Afzal1,2, Imran Khan1,2, Intisar Ud Din1,2, Ilyas Ahmad7, Muhammad Younas1,2, Muhammad Kamran1,2 and Cheng-xiao Hu1,2*

Author Affiliations

1Key Laboratory of Arable Land Conservation (Middle and Lower Reaches of Yangtze River), Ministry of Agriculture, Micro-elements Research Center, College of Resource and Environment, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

2Hubei Provincial Engineering Laboratory for New Fertilizers, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

3Department of Soil Science, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan, Pakistan

4College of Plant Science, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

5University of Agriculture Faisalabad Sub Campus Burewala Vehari, Pakistan

6National Key Laboratory of Crop Genetic Improvement, College of Life Science and Technology, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

7Soil and Water Testing Laboratory for Research, Multan, Pakistan

Received: December 20, 2019 | Published: January 21, 2020

Corresponding author:Cheng-xiao Hu, Key Laboratory of Arable Land Conservation (Middle and Lower Reaches of Yangtze River), Ministry of Agriculture, Micro-elements Research Center, College of Resource and Environment, Hubei Provincial Engineering Laboratory for New Fertilizers, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

DOI: 10.26717/BJSTR.2020.24.004104

Abstract

Background: Molybdenum for plant growth is essential micronutrient wherever in enzyme catalysis it is required as catalytically active metal. Functional roles are fulfilled by molybdenum in enzyme systems in plants. Enzymes more than 50 Mo-containing are recognized, maximum of them are of bacterial origin, while a few Mo-enzymes are seen amongst eukaryotes. Five Mo-enzymes in plants, to this end are identified: AO, NR, SO, mARC and XDH which catalyze vital significant reactions in degradation of purine, synthesis of phytohormone, nitrogen assimilation and detoxification of sulfite.

Scope: The enzymes are significant regardless of having common structural elements, in the series of diverse chemical reactions those are being catalyzed, even though nearly all reactions are two electron oxidation reduction in this an atom of oxygen is transferred from or to the Mo. XDH family enzymes are described best mononuclear enzymes having molybdenum. This article will emphasis on computational approaches to those plant enzymes which requisite Mo as catalytic metal, focusing on their functions, key mechanisms, current prospects and future challenges.

Conclusion: Plants distress from deficiency of Mo is limited in growth and development, their leaves shows paleness, disorders in flower formation and ultimately withers. So, molybdenum nutrition for healthy growth and development of plant is key essential where it is being obligatory as a metal that is catalytically active in catalysis of enzymes (NR, SO, XDH, AO and mARC) that accomplishes functional roles in plants enzyme systems and known to participate in numerous redox reactions and results in proper plant growth and development while they have significant positions both in the redox biogeochemical cycles of N, S and C on earth and in the individual organism metabolism.Thus, prompt improvement in our understanding of Mo enzymes role and function in plants will help us that how it will be helpful for the proper plant functioning regarding their responses and metabolism.

Keywords: Molybdenum; Nitratereductse; Aldehyde Oxidase; Xanthine Dehydrogenase; Sulfite Oxidase; Mitochondrial Amidoximereductase; Inefficiency; Toxicity

Introduction

Molybdenum in enzymes as catalytic center has chemical adaptability, which is valuable to biological systems, in physiological conditions, it is redox-active. To catalyze diverse redox reactions molybdenum, possess versatile redox chemistry which is utilized by enzymes. At enzyme environment and Mo atom, this redox chemistry is controlled both by different ligands [1]. The molybdate anion in soils is the only Mo form available to plants. For life enzymes having Mo are of vital importance, subsequently they have significant positions both in the redox biogeochemical cycles of N, S and C on earth and in the individual organism metabolism [2-4]. More than 50 Mo-containing enzymes are known to be Mo-dependent, Mo five enzymes in plants still are known: sulfite oxidase (SO), mARC (mitochondrial amidoxime reductase), XDH (xanthine dehydrogenase), NR (nitrate reductase) and AO (aldehyde oxidase) Table 1 [5,6]. In cytosol NR is localized that catalyses the nitrate into nitrite reduction. By NiR (nitrite reductase) that is to be found in plastids, into ammonium nitrite is reduced and into amino acids this ammonium via GSGOGAT cycle this is further assimilated. In assimilation pathway of nitrate as NR is the key primary enzyme that is why in plants deficiency of Mo often leads to N deficiency. To peroxisome SO is localized that oxidizes the sulphite (toxic) into sulphate, in opposite way to the assimilation of reductive sulphate that take place in plastids [7]. For purine degradation XDH is required in N-metabolism and can produce ROS (reactive oxygen species) and AO takes part in ABA (abscisic acid) synthesis, glucosinolates, auxin, and probably, further compounds in plants [8-11].

Table 1: Mo enzyme in plant (Arabidopsis thaliana).

In divergence to other Mo containing enzymes, eukaryotic mARC (Mitochondrial amidoximereductase) proteins does not show enzymatic action their own but needs other proteins like NADH/ cytochromeb5 and cytochromeb5 reductase as transmitters electron and donor’s electron, respectively (Mendel, 2011). Once molybdate come into the cell it is consequently integrated through the complex biosynthetic machineries into metal cofactors. Then these metal cofactors into different enzymes are incorporated [12]. There are two molybdoenzyme distinctive forms, molybdenum nitrogenase have unique cluster molybdenum–iron–sulfur, called FeMoco [13]. The reduction of atmospheric dinitrogen to ammonia is catalyzes by nitrogenase. Other molybdoenzymes are oxidoreductases that transmit two electrons or an oxo group to or from substrate. They possess Mo cofactor in that Mo is coordinated to a dithiolene group on pterin 6-alkyl side chain called MPT (molybdopterin) [14,15]. This review will concentrate on computational approaches to enzymes containing Mo, focusing on their functions, key mechanisms, current prospects and future challenges.

Symptoms of Molybdenum Deficiency and Molybdenum Excess in Crops

Molybdenum insufficiencies predominantly related with poor N health mainly when nitrate is major available N form for growth of plant. Plants distress from deficiency of Mo is limited in growth and development, their leaves shows paleness, disorders in flower formation and ultimately withers. In dicotyledons irregularities in formation of leaf blade (whiptail) and severe decline in size are being seen the most visual typical symptoms. These are due to vascular bundles insufficient differentiation on initial leaf development phases and the local necrosis in tissue [16]. Mo insufficient plants have characteristic phenotype containing altered morphology of leaves and lesions [17]. In maximum plant species, the NR activity loss is related with nitrate increased tissue concentrations and reduction in yields and growth of plant [18].In view of that, in the plants of spinach that is grown under deficiency of Mo, activity of leaf NR was reduced and final yields of plant was lesser than that of control where adequate amount of Mo received by plant. In wheat, Mo insufficiency also indicated decreased activities of NR regardless of NR regulatory control by dark and light periods [19,20]. Mo resupply as foliar or in nutrient solution in most cases recovers activity of NR [19]. In Vitis vinifera, during establishment poor growth and in mature plants variable yields grown in various vineyards of South Australian is positively interrelated with reduced petiolar levels of molybdenum [21].

At various diverse levels deficiency of Mo affects plant metabolism. The responses intensely associated to the Mo requirement for numerous molybdoenzymes types existing in the plants. Deficiency of Mo may also be due to a mutation in particular Mo uptake system [22-24]. Defect in biosynthesis of Moco, can cause Mo deficiency that has intense consequences for cell because all Mo containing enzymes activities pleiotropically are strongly reduced or lost. Molybdoenzymes of plant could be split down to those involved in N assimilation and reduction i.e. nitrate reduction (NR), nitrogen fixation (nitrogenase), indole-3 acetic acid (IAA) synthesis (AO), abscisic acid (ABA),sulfur metabolism (SO) and purine catabolism (XDH). SO and NR comprise of dioxo Mo cofactor, that stimulates protein when in protein complex, it is inserted (Mendel and Haensch, 2002). AO and XDH have a monoxo Mo cofactor that needs Moco insertion and after that following Mo centre sulfuration to stimulate complex Moco/protein [25-27]. AAO3 is essential for transformation of the abscisic aldehyde into ABA, therefore that one loss cause wilty phenotype that is severe for plant survival [28,29]. Whereas a knockout in one of two mARC proteins have not any evident phenotype and deficiency of Moco-sulfurase (ABA3) was seen to be mainly recognized to ABA levels reduction due to absence of activities of AOand therefore wilty phenotype [30]. Since Mo is takes part in different enzymatic processes, a clear plant reaction to deficiency of Mo could be complex and therefore tough to allocate causally to particular enzyme systems. In molybdoenzymes this is mainly evident involved in metabolism of N where overall reductions plant health and growth can modify development of plant, grain or fruit development and pest damage susceptibility [31]

Molybdenum insufficiency causing the deficiency of N in legumes that are relying on fixation of N2 is widespread, principally in the acidic mineral soils of sub humid and humid tropics. The reports indicated that Mo foliar applications in the field conditions to the grain legumes upsurge nodule mass and N2 fixation levels, that results in overall high seed yield and N content [32]. In the laboratory circumstances, numerous legumes that were severely Mo starved exhibited more dramatic deficiency signs. This is also being described that Mo transport deficient B. japonicum strain exhibited reduced fixation activity of N when it is inoculated to roots of soybean. In Vitis vinifera during establishment variable yields and poor growth in the mature plants in various vineyards of South Australian is interrelated positively with reduced petiolar Mo levels [21].

In contrast, toxicity of Mo in maximum agricultural conditions in plants is rare. Mo toxicity and availability to plants is strappingly reliant on properties of soil and its occurrence as anionic species, so plants take Mo in molybdate anions form (MoO42− and HMoO4−) that are in soil solution, predominant species [33,34]. At low pH protonation takes place where H2MoO4 (diprotonated monomer) and HMoO4− (monoprotonated monomer) can perform a related role. The grouping of three monomer species and isopolymolybdates three other (protonated heptamer, heptamer and octamer) interprets in equilibrium for all species in aqueous solutions having pH 2–7 and concentrations of molybdate amongst 0.03 mM and 0.1 M. Though, for soils havingpH more than 4.0, MoO42− is principal available form [35]. Properties of soil like amorphous iron (Fe), texture, Al hydroxides/ oxides, and O.M could also affect Mo uptake by plants. [36,37] demonstrated the soil properties significance on the bioavailability and toxicity of metal cations that are divalent as Cu, Co and Ni. But, contrasting to cationic metals, generally Mo availability to higher plant species upsurges with increasing pH of soil. [38] determined that Pisum sativum L. plants the Mo highest concentration (1 mM) tested inhibited yield of shoot and root respectively, by 35% and 50%, Besides conditions of soil solution and properties of soil, plants Mo accumulation is also reliant on the plant species e.g. Brassica species are recognized to accumulate Mo [39-41].

Functions of Molybdenum in Plants

Figure 1: From NO (Nitrite) enzymes anticipated to yield nitric oxide. Through catalytic Moco domain Mo-enzymes proposed to facilitate NO production (2a) while extra systems that also have been suggested to facilitate the NO production (2b) (Sakihama et al. [42-46).

In plants, Mo-enzymes NR, SO, XDH, AO and mARC have key essential functions [6]. Figure 1; From NO (Nitrite) enzymes anticipated to yield nitric oxide. Through catalytic Moco domain Mo-enzymes proposed to facilitate NO production (1a) while extra systems that also have been suggested to facilitate the NO production (1b) [42-46]. For different Mo-enzymes in production of NO, nitrite been proposed to be a substrate, can be in use up by cells, but is mainly the nitrate reduction product at the NR active center (Figure 1) [47]. Plants Mo-enzymes into two families are classified dependent on how Moco binds to the active site of enzyme, either covalently by an enzyme cysteine thiol group (NR, SO, and ARC) or by means of an inorganic sulfur (XDH and AOX). In NR, AO, SO, mARC, XDH all of the activities of NO-synthesizing has been revealed to be active under anaerobiosis and in vitro by use of nitrite as a substrate [13,45,46]. These have very crucial role for growth optimization, yield and development of plants, their key importance and crucial role in proper plant functioning is described below.

NR and Its Function

NRs are enzymes by which nitrate assimilation catalyze, nitrate reduction to nitrite by means of a Mo cofactor. In an alternate reaction, plant NRs have also revealed to catalyze nitrite reduction to nitric oxide, and this seems in plant to be a main source for synthesis of nitric oxide [48]. DFT (Density functional theory) results showed that although for NR active site nitrate is thermodynamically the preferable substrate, nitrate and nitrite both easily reduced to NO and nitrite, respectively. Mo (IV) state is needed by these mechanisms. Moreover, in nitrite case, linkage isomerism is at work and controlled by oxidation state of metal and reduction is, unlike in the case of nitrate, dependent upon protonation. As thereby NR to plant provides essential N metabolites, it is evident that NR deficient plants are no longer N autotroph and depend on N alternate sources as like ammonium. The NR monomer comprises of distinct three domains [49]: with Moco N-terminal domain linked, and domain FAD-binding with C-terminal, domain cytochromeb5 with the central heme-binding, whereby such two monomers form active homodimeric enzyme. Enzyme substrates standard redox potentials (Eo′) and prosthetic groups of the enzyme involved are shown in Figure 2 [50]. Electron is indicated by arrows from NADPH to nitrate by numerous prosthetic groups with a favorable electrochemical potential gradient. These prosthetic groups are bound to isolated domains of protein that are interconnected through hinge flexible regions. By regions protease sensitive hinge these domains are linked called hinge I and II. Hinge I in plants, the linker among Moco and cytochromeb5 domain, has a conserved serine residue which intervenes interaction with protein 14-3-3 when phosphorylated, consequently leading to enzyme activity inhibition [51].

Figure 2: NR ETC scheme.

Nitrate assimilation regulation is part of network that is complex regulatory replying to internal signals and diverse environment as like metabolites of C and N, metabolism nitrate, CO2, light, and phytohormones, in order to coordinate assimilation of nitrate with other significant metabolic processes [52,53]. The NR regulation includes both post translational and transcriptional mechanisms that are regulating the amount as well as NR protein activity. NR protein is phosphorylated in dark, thus allowing NR inhibitor protein stoichiometric binding that belongs to 14‐3‐3 class proteins [51]. On leaves illumination, by dephosphorylation and dissociation of the inhibitor protein NR is rapidly reactivated. Dephosphorylated NR cannot be inhibited by inhibitor protein. Starting at nitrate transporters, signal transduction flow and nitrate linking availability to the transcription induction is still mysterious, but in research receives a lot of attention nowadays. There are signs that nitrate not only serves as substrate for assimilation, but also for coordinating C and N metabolism as regulatory signal and driving root development [54-58].

NR efficient turnover as nitrate reductase as conflicting to nitrite reductase duty depend either on nitrite efficient expulsion from active site, or onto the electronic structure distinctiveness of the active site of Mo that will favor nitrate reduction and binding over nitrite reduction and binding [59]. In current years nitrate reduction has been computationally explored at Mo center of NR, from crystal structure data particularly benefiting [60]. Around active site, significant amino acids were recognized, and their role in fine-tuning reactivity towards the electrons and nitrate were explored in some detail [61]. By NR the nitrite reduction exact mechanism is unknown. This mechanism might include coordination of nitrite via one or two oxygen atoms, or via N. As another plant NR regulatory region, N terminal extension preceding the Moco domain was shown to be involved in the posttranscriptional regulation by light [62]. NR specific forms NADH in higher plants are most abundant; however specific forms NADPH occur among fungi [63,64]. It is significant that inside protein Moco is completely buried and cone like structure leads from the protein surface to active site. Whereas in nitrogen assimilation nitrite is further reduced to ammonium by nitrite reductase in chloroplasts, by NR itself it can also be reduced to signaling molecule nitric oxide (NO) [65]. As NR post-translational modification also modulated the rates of NO production, it was determined that indeed NR is a active nitrogen species producer also in vivo [66].

Accordingly, grown under Mo deficiency disorders in spinach plants, NR activity in the leaf was found to be decreased and final plant yields grown on sufficient levels of Mo, overall lower than control plants [18,19]. Mo insufficiency in wheat, was also revealed to reduce maximum activities of NR irrespective of the NR regulatory control through periods dark and light [67]. As foliar spray Mo resupplying or in nutrient solution supplemented in maximum instances will recover readily NR activity [19]. In Merlot phenotype present it would indicate not related to activity and synthesis of Moco or NR apoenzyme but associated with a disturbance in mechanism that are monitoring Mo uptake or inner redistribution in phloem and xylem [22].

AO and Its Function

AO enzymes are alike to XDH upon an early gene duplication that is derived from XDH. Coextensive with this, both enzymes show a high degree use of same prosthetic groups and sequence similarity which catalyze the oxidation of a variety of nonaromatic and aromatic aldehydes and heterocycles, so converting them to respective carboxylic acid as they share a more degree of sequence homology, so that during evolution it is presumed that from XDH, AO has been derived by neo-functionalization and gene duplication. Then XDH, AOs display a greatly substrate specificity, covering aldehydes, aliphatic and aromatic heterocycles as well as pteridines and purines while 300 kDa apparent molecular mass and therefore with XDH shares structural and catalytical similarities. AO proteins in contrast to XDH preferably oxidize aldehydes to respective carboxylic acid. Furthermore, during catalysis molecular oxygen is exclusive electron acceptor and its consumption is obligatorily linked with the generation of hydrogen superoxide and peroxide anions [9,68]. However, main differences are present regarding the binding of substrate at center of Mo and physiological electron acceptor [69,70]. AO is a severe oxidase that is being not capable to bind NAD but solely with molecular oxygen usage as electron acceptor. The fact that IAA belongs to the plant hormones auxin family proposes a probable physiological role of AO enzymes in biosynthesis of auxin throughout plant early stages development. The characteristics most prominent that differentiate AO from XDH enzymes found to concern binding of substrate at the molybdenum center and physiological electron acceptor binding [71].

In A. thaliana four AAO1–AAO4, AO genes were recognized whose products forms the heterodimers, homodimers as well as thus lead to changed respective isoenzymes substrate specificities [72-74]. For AAO1 and AAO2, both efficiently catalyze in vitro indole acetaldehyde oxidation to indole-3-acetic acid. AAO4 in siliques is expressed preferably and catalyzes the benzaldehyde oxidation into benzoic acid and latter being amalgamated into glucosinolates that serve as defense compounds of herbivore [11]. AO enzymes are the firm oxidases that unable to bind NAD+ and solely usage molecular oxygen as an electron acceptor, thus generating hydrogen peroxide [9].AAO1 and AAO2 gene products, in seedlings six day old form heterodimers and homodimers, AO isoenzymes that are capable of making indole 3 acetic acid[72]. Arabidopsis mutants with AAO3 deficiency hence by reduced level of ABA are characterized accompanied through excessive loss of water and wilty phenotype, reduced stress tolerance and stunted vegetative growth [74].

AO isoform AAO3 by abscisic aldehyde turns superlative as substrate. Abscisic aldehyde is native precursor of absicisic acid plant hormone that is vital for numerous growing processes as well as for a variety of biotic and abiotic stress responses [75-77]. Another AO isoform known is AOδ that is required for abscisic aldehyde oxidation producing the abscisic acid phytohormone [8]. For various developmental processes and for various biotic and abiotic stress responses, Abscisic acid is essential for these [77]. Mutant analysis and tissue distribution from the specificity of substrate it could be concluded that Arabidopsis AO3 catalyses the transformation of abscisic aldehyde to ABA (abscisic acid), the final step in ABA‐biosynthesis [78,79]. In the IAA over producing mutant sur1, AO1 activity is being found five times greater as compared to wild type of Arabidopsis [80]. Thus, for numerous physiological processes, AO is extremely significant in plants including the onset of senescence. Other AO isoenzymes are involved in auxin phytohormones biosynthesis in early plant development stages.

By high preference, the homodime AAO3 is considered for the abscisic aldehyde as substrate [74], that is the ultimate ABA precursor which is involved in numerous features of plant development and growth, together with maturation of seed, leaf senescence dormancy, and adaptation to diversity of environmental stresses absolutely use the molecular oxygen as electron acceptor. Upon transfer of substrate-derived electrons to molecular oxygen, plant AO generates hydrogen peroxide [9]. Recently, levels of AAO3 protein by ubiquitin reliant degradation have shown to be controlled via 26S proteasome to avoid premature senescence through ABA accumulation [81]. This proposes that during the senescence onset, in AO proteins the synthesis of ABA also play an acute role that needs a tight control of levels of AO and ABA. From maize, Arabidopsis and tomato, the AO gene has been cloned where four AO cDNAs were seen and mapped physically to dissimilar chromosomes [82,83]. The isoforms of encoded enzyme have comparatively extensive substrate specificity for numerous aldehydes comprising indole‐3‐acetaldehyde, abscisic aldehyde, benzaldehyde and indole‐3‐aldehyde. The extensive AO substrate specificity creates it likely that AOs are involved in extra metabolic reactions other than the synthesis of phytohormone. Response of pathogen and reactions detoxification might be good applicants for these additional functions. Therefore, in plants AO enzymes are vital for several physiological processes that need absicisic acid involvement and also maybe of auxins. Because of the ABA function in many aspects of plant development and growth and in a range of abiotic stresses adaptation, with reduced levels of ABA, plants deficient in AAO3 are described by more transpiration rate, impaired seed dormancy and reduced stress tolerance [84].

XDH and Its Function

XDH is the important key enzyme of purine degradation. XDH needs FAD, Moco, and the two iron sulfur clusters [85]. XDH like all Mo-enzymes, is a functional dimer comprises of two alike subunits. By a molecular mass 300 kDa plant XDH is homodimeric [86] and XDH was seen also to catalyze ROS substrate independent formation because of an intrinsic NADH oxidase activity. XDH is active as a homodimer of two alike subunits, each one being subdivided in distinct three domains, N terminal domain for binding two clusters [2Fe-2S], a FAD-binding site domain, and a C terminal domain necessary for dimerization and Moco binding. Plant XDH displays maximum affinities for hypoxanthine and xanthine as substrate, but it also at much lower rates accepts pterins and purines [87].

XDH each subunit consists of three distinctive domains essential for two [2Fe–2S] clusters binding, FAD and Moco, respectively, while domain essential for dimerization is merged to domain Moco binding. Into distinct three domains, monomer could be subdivided, domain N-terminal for two [2Fe-2S] type clusters binding, a FADbinding site domain, and C terminal domain that is essential for dimerization and Moco-binding. Electrons resulting upon substrate conversion are nourished in intra molecular electron transmission enzyme chain and go from the center of Mo via clusters [2Fe–2S] to cofactor FAD. Here to form NADH electrons either transferred to NAD, or to molecular oxygen, therefore producing superoxide anions [9] and might, so, into reactive oxygen metabolism have supplementary physiological functions because of increasing XDH activities. At NAD+ tremendously lower concentrations, as alternate electron acceptor molecular oxygen can assist with simultaneous superoxides generation [88]. Plant XDH production of ROS may be of physiological significance because XDH increasing activities and ROS simultaneous production were detected upon interactions of plant–pathogen, natural senescence, drought stress, hypersensitive response and virus infection [89-91].

During senescence oxidative processes comprise enzyme activities increase producing superoxide ions and oxygen radicals. In leaves of pea, activity of XDH was increased sharply in analogous with enzymes related to oxygen and superoxide dismutase [92]. The XDH function is crucial as showed by plants that are deficient in XDH, for plant growth, fertility and senescence [93]. XDH displays strong intrinsic activity of NADH oxidase that is complemented by consumption of oxygen as an electron acceptor and simultaneous superoxide anions formation [88]. It is guessed that this key activity has significance in the abiotic and biotic stresses response. With microbodies XDH could be related and later this was described that peroxisomes in pea leaf have activity of XDH that catabolizes inside the organelles, xanthine to uric acid. In contrast, in nodules of cowpea, XDH immunocytochemistry revealed a cytoplasmic location, and in the Arabidopsis XDH sequence no targeting signal was found [94,95]. In Arabidopsis two genes were founded that are situated in genome side by side, encoding XDH1 and XDH2 isoenyzmes [90]. Activity of XDH increases when the phytopathogenic fungi Uromyces or Puccinia infect legumes and cereals [96]. Whether this response is aimed at oxidative defence mechanisms it still unknown; however, in pea, XDH activity is strongly correlated with the activity of superoxide dismutase [92].

The fixed nitrogen export and mobilization out of nodule needs the molybdoenzyme XDH activity. Dependent on species of legume, fixed N is exported as either ureides or amides, that are derived initially from purines oxidative breakdown. In this process, hypoxanthin conversion to xanthine and conversion of the xanthine to uric acid is catalyses by XDH [26]. Onto the activity of XDH, the direct special effects of deficiencies of Mo in nodules of legume could affect on the plants ability to export proficiently reduced N from nodule. It is poorly understanding that how other and this response related plant defense are interconnected to plant Mo nutrition is understood poorly. With lesser numeral of studies exception, to conclude there is slight straight evidence that in plant Mo levels improvements results in a reduction of disease, that indicates in tomato verticillium wilt fertilization of Mo can increase resistance [31]. Furthermore, to the xanthine and hypoxanthine dependent construction of ROS also with superoxide simultaneous production, activities of NADH oxidase have been revealed for plant XDH [88]. As this activity is highly prominent, this suggests that XDH is an effective superoxide producer in vivo also, and that enzyme could be involved in NADH and NAD cellular regulation balance.

SO and Its Function

The SO enzyme is significant for sulfite detoxification, i.e. the sulfite oxidation to sulfate and has 90 kDa molecular mass for dimer. In chloroplasts in the course of primary sulphate assimilation, sulphate via sulphite is reduced to organic sulphide that is used for biosynthesis of cysteine [97-99]. In plant kingdom the gene SO is greatly conserved and widespread. As redox center, SO retains only Moco and together with mARC, is the simplest Mo enzyme found in eukaryotes. However, Plant SO enzyme, is peroxisomal enzyme that as electron acceptor uses molecular oxygen and during catalysis forms hydrogen peroxide simultaneously [7,100,101]. The latter fact could describe the SO peroxisomal localization since during oxidation of sulfite, excess hydrogen peroxide generated, by catalase may eliminated easily. As sulfite is being sturdy nucleophile that can react with a wide range of cellular components it was supposed that SO possesses function of sulfite detoxifying and is necessary for eliminating surplus sulfite from cell [7,27]. In support of this, [27] found independently that in comparison to plants wild type plants deficient in SO are more susceptible to sulfite high concentrations while overexpressing SO plants are more excess sulfite tolerant. However, in normal situations, in plants the loss of the activity of SO is not associated to an apparent phenotype, suggesting that rather than housekeeping metabolic enzyme, SO symbolizes salvage enzyme [102]. Though, it also been described that back to sulphate, sulphite could be oxidized, e.g., when SO2 gas subjected to plants or, when the isolated chloroplasts were fed with labelled sulphite radioactively. Activity of Sulphite oxidizing was identified in the dark and light [103,104]. Therefore, sulphate assimilation would be counteracting by SO, providing that in chloroplast it would be localized. In normal conditions, SO is submitted to be sulfate sulfite cycle part which is highly important for sulfur distribution fine tuning in cell.

The compartmentalization of sulphur assimilation and sulphite oxidation in different organelles allows plants to coregulate these opposing metabolic demands. In chloroplasts oxidation of sulfite was seen to be increaseable by the light and sensitive to photosynthetic electron transport inhibitors and thus due to the reactions that are non-enzymatic was interpreted to be mainly during the electron transport [105]. Though, there exists a new sulfite oxidizing activity that also happens in dark and can be pelleted when isolated chloroplasts are broken. From spinach chloroplasts, latter activity was purified, and it has been found to be connected with the thylakoid membranes [103, 105,106]. Plant SO known to date amongst eukaryotes, the one that is lacking active redox centres other than the Moco. The association of SOs Moco domains from different sources with Arabidopsis NR and SO shows significant whole homology, pinpointing these enzymes such as members of the common family [98]. Amongst higher plants Plant SO is conserved as evinced by fact that upraised antibodies against Arabidopsis SO identified a dominantly protein band cross reacting of almost 45 kDa in an extensive variety of species belonging to range of both woody herbacious plants.

Mitochondrial Amidoximereductase and Its Function

mARC (mitochondrial amidoxime reducing component) was exposed as fifth eukaryotic Mo cofactor having enzyme [107]. For Mo-enzymes and Moco biosynthesis, all genomes of eukaryotes well-known to encode the proteins, as well encode two proteins mARC, proposing that the mARC proteins custom an own minor protein family [108]. All mARC eukaryotic proteins comprising the counterparts of the plant, which forecast these proteins mitochondrial localization, are described by N-terminal extensions presence. With average 35 kDa molecular mass and because of fact that as only prosthetic group they bind Moco, mARC protein are the smallest Mo-enzymes identified as yet. It is supposed that in metabolism they show detoxifying role. mARC is the three protein amidoxime reducing chain catalytic partner which consist of also cytochrome b5 reductase and NADH dependent cytochrome b5, that are involved in transfer of electron from NADH to mARC (Figure 3) [109].

Figure 3: Schematic representation of the mARC-containing enzymatic system, comprising mARC, cytochrome b5 (cyt. b5) and NADH dependent cytochrome b5 reductase.

In contrast, entirely other Mo enzymes, mARC eukaryotic proteins not show on their own the enzymatic activity but need other proteins alike NADH, cytochrome b5 reductase and cytochrome b5 as electron donors and electron transmitters, respectively thus forming the mARC enzyme complex [110].The two other proteins, CYB5R (cytochromeb5 reductase) and CYB5 (cytochrome b5), from NADH to terminal oxidoreductase, mARC catalyze transfer of electron [110]. NO (nitric oxide) from nitrite can be generated by mARC when forming a chain of electron transfer with NADH, NADH- dependent cytochrome b5 reductase and cytochrome b5. When pH decreased from 7.5 to 6.5, the NO formation rate rises threefold. [111] conducted the experiment to determine if reduction of nitrite is catalyzed through Mo in mARC-1 active site, they mutated Cys-273 (putative active site cysteine residue), known to coordinate Mo binding. N-hydroxylated nucleobases and HAPR (N-hydroxy- adenosine) or nucleosides as HAP (N-hydroxylaminopurine) may be endogenously generated in course of metabolism of cell by cytochrome P450, biosynthesis of deviating nucleotide or oxidative stress. For eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells these compounds have revealed to be the toxic and mutagenic. For replication of DNA dependability, it is thus of key significance that organisms to eradicate such non canonical base correspondents from DNA precursor tarns display operative mechanisms. In vitro, mARC1 and mARC2 have revealed to be proficient of reducing N nucleoside analogs and hydroxylated base analogs to resultant canonical nucleosides and nucleobases on reconstruction with electron transport proteins CYB5 and NADH- CYB5R [112]. As a sole prosthetic group mARC protein bind Moco [110]. mARC proteins belong to the SO-family most likely, but final confirmation needs to be provided [Figure 3].

Role of Molybdenum in Abiotic Stress Mediation

Mo have significant roles in resisting numerous environmental stresses, such as drought, salt stress and cold [113-118]. Amongst the abiotic stresses low temperature is the most important affecting plant growth, development, distribution and production all over the world. Under cold stress in the winter wheat, Mo was having progressive impacts on drought stress, rates and products of photosynthesis. Through the antioxidative enzymes escalating activities Mo also boosted the turf grass chilling resistance [20,118-120] revealed that Mo reduced Cd concentration under the Cd stress. Moreover, as a result of Mo excess or deficiency it has been described that the biomass, product quality and seed yield all deteriorated [121]. Low temperatures can be tolerated by some plants in a process that is called as cold acclimation, this happens when plants are wide-open to non-freezing low temperature (40C) [122,123]. Throughout the process of acclimation, various alterations happen such as osmoprotectants accumulation alike amines, soluble sugar, and compatible solutes such as proline, polyols, and betaine, through activation of low temperature signal pathways of transduction that ultimately lead to transformed gene expression and membrane stability to provide tolerance at all levels [124-126].

In Arabidopsis intensive studies on cold response gene expression led to the DREB1/CBF transcription factors identification that has a crucial role in plants during freezing and cold acclimation stress tolerance [127]. In the cold promoters and genes responsive for dehydration, these transcription factors also bind to sequences of specific regulatory. These sequences are elements responsive for dehydration and C-repeat. These both sequences have the highly 5-bp conserved sequence of CCGAC that has the ability to transcription regulation in drought, salinity and temperature [128]. Therefore, CBF induces the COR genes expression and in plant cold tolerance improvement these genes have an important crucial role. [129,130] reported the Mo optimistic influence on the improvement of cold tolerance in the cauliflower without acclimation.

Earlier study showed that under cold stress, deficiency of Mo inhibits the chlorophyll biosynthesis and leads to chlorophyll decrease in cultivars of winter wheat [131] and through Mo application showed the positive effect on stomatal conductance, photosynthetic rate and decreased transpiration rate in winter wheat under stress of low temperature[118,132].On the other hand, in chickpea excess Mo reduced the biomass, lessened the produce quality and yield of seed yield [121,115] and [133]have stated that for wheat gene expression may be altered not just by decreased in temperature (4 0C), but subsequent disclosure to certain chemicals that were used for priming of seed e.g. Mo, that can upsurge the expression of CBF. Moreover, this study also indicated that to tolerate decrease in temperature these chemicals improved the ability of plants due to the ABA biosynthesis regulation via AO, and ABA is takes part in mediating of COR (Cold regulated) expression of genes. In the meantime, [115] have described that the activity of AO, IAA and ABA content increased in wheat leaves that were treated with Mo. It also been earlier suggested that in frost damage amelioration, Mo can be involved [133,134].

Worldwide drought stress as a main environmental stress is well known that limits the crop plants development, yield and growth, and can generate a series of biochemical and physiological plants responses [135]. The main biochemical and physiological characteristics not just associated to photosynthesis inhibition, decline in transpiration, decline in chlorophyll content and stomata closure but are involved also in ability of osmotic adjustment and antioxidant that are significant ways to increase resistance of plant to drought capacity [136]. Numerous studies have presented that drought stress may result in more active oxygen species production such as hydroxyl radicals, superoxides and superoxide radical [137], that results membrane damage and cell death [138-140] reported that the antioxidant enzymes activities such as superoxide dismutase, ascorbate peroxidase, peroxidase, catalase, and nonenzymatic antioxidants content like ascorbic acid, carotenoid, reduced glutathione, were increased significantly and decreased malonaldehyde contents through application of Mo in drought stress, suggesting that application of Mo improved the scavenging ability of species of active oxygen. Through increasing the antioxidant enzymes activities active oxygen species are scavenged by plants such as CAT (catalase), SOD (superoxide dismutase), APX (ascorbate peroxidase) and POD (peroxidase) or through enhancing non-enzymatic antioxidants levels such as, GSH (glutathione), AsA (ascorbic acid) and CAR (carotenoid)[141,142].

Furthermore, in plants to resist stress of drought osmotic adjustment also is significant way. The substances that help in osmoregulation such as proline, soluble proteins and soluble sugar also show important roles in osmotic equilibrium maintenance and under deficiency water the integrity of membranes [143]. The wheat drought tolerance might be improved through the application of Mo by enhancing utilization capability of water, antioxidative defense abilities and osmotic adjustment. It is described also that overexpression sulfurase gene Mo cofactor confers drought tolerance in tobacco, soybean, cotton and maize [144]. Environmental adversative conditions comprising soil salinity, heavy metal contamination and water stress can affect intensely on plants nitrogen assimilation, this rises from the stress effect on nitrogenase and nitrate reductase enzymes activity. [116] have showed that Chinese cabbage fresh weight increased significantly by the Mo application under the salt stress. They also indicated that under salt stress the nonenzymatic antioxidants contents and antioxidant enzyme activities were extraordinarily enhanced by application of Mo. By Mo application accumulating products of the Osmotic adjustment were also increased dramatically under salt stress. Furthermore, the ratios Na+-K+ were increased intensely and with the Mo application rates were correlated positively. Hence, we can see that the Mo application tolerance to salinity was improved by the osmotic stress tolerance and increasing eliminating active oxygen ability. [145] studied the Mo deficiency stress effect on viability, seedling growth and seed germination of wheat and described that deficiency of Mo results in necrotic spots on wheat leaves and wrinkled and poor seeds. [67] also reported a remarkable reduction in activity of nitrate reductase and metabolism of nitrogen under deficiency of Mo [146-150].

Concluding Remarks and Future Prospects

Molybdenum nutrition for healthy growth and development of plant is key essential where it is being obligatory as a metal that is catalytically active in catalysis of enzymes that accomplishes functional roles in plants enzyme systems and known to participate in numerous redox reactions. Five Mo-enzymes in plants are identified to this end: NR, AO SO, XDH, and mARC that catalyze key significant reactions in nitrogen assimilation, phytohormone synthesis, sulfite detoxification and purine degradation. NR catalyses the nitrate reduction into nitrite and SO oxidizes sulphite that toxic into sulphate. In the nitrogen metabolism for degradation of purine XDH is needed and can produce ROS while AO is involved in the ABA synthesis, glucosinolates and auxin. mARC are the smallest Mo enzymes identified as yet showing the detoxifying role. Current years have conveyed prompt improvement in our understanding of Mo role and function in plants. Evidently, research focuses on studying the Mo enzymes structure–function relationships. However, a still large number of unresolved questions is there that requisite to be answered.

a) What additional metabolic reactions by AO family member are catalyzed?
b) The question during senescence what exact role XDH plays in metabolism of activated oxygen, remains to be answered?
c) Why in peroxisomes the SO is localalized? And what SO plays the exact role?
d) In details, how molybdate transporter is being organized?
e) For biosynthesis of Moco, how the multi-enzyme complex organized? What is Moco insertion mechanism into the apoenzymes? To meet the cell changing demands for Moco how is Moco biosynthesis has been regulated?
f) What factors effect tungsten incorporation instead of the Mo in some enzymes?
g) What key roles CnX4 have is not so much clear?

Future research Mo enzymes field is likely to emphasis on detailed mechanistic of cofactors functions, biosynthesis of cofactor and their allocation in specific enzymes. Considerable further research is necessary to ascertain that how the element in the future may be used to develop growing areas where molybdate soil profiles limit the growth of plant. The years coming, into these will bring insight and perhaps Mo novel aspects within the physiological and metabolic cell network.

Acknowledgement

None.

Conflict of Interest

No conflict of interest.

References

Review Article

Molybdenum as an Essential Element for Crops: An Overview

Muhammad Shoaib Rana1,2, Parashuram Bhantana1,2, Xue-cheng Sun1,2, Muhammad Imran1,2 Muhammad Shaaban3, Mohamed G. Moussa1,2, Muhammad Hamzah Saleem4, Ali Mohamed Elyamine1,2, Rana Binyamin5, Mufid Alam6, Javaria Afzal1,2, Imran Khan1,2, Intisar Ud Din1,2, Ilyas Ahmad7, Muhammad Younas1,2, Muhammad Kamran1,2 and Cheng-xiao Hu1,2*

Author Affiliations

1Key Laboratory of Arable Land Conservation (Middle and Lower Reaches of Yangtze River), Ministry of Agriculture, Micro-elements Research Center, College of Resource and Environment, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

2Hubei Provincial Engineering Laboratory for New Fertilizers, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

3Department of Soil Science, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan, Pakistan

4College of Plant Science, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

5University of Agriculture Faisalabad Sub Campus Burewala Vehari, Pakistan

6National Key Laboratory of Crop Genetic Improvement, College of Life Science and Technology, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

7Soil and Water Testing Laboratory for Research, Multan, Pakistan

Received:December 20, 2019 | Published: January 21, 2020

Corresponding author:Cheng-xiao Hu, Key Laboratory of Arable Land Conservation (Middle and Lower Reaches of Yangtze River), Ministry of Agriculture, Micro-elements Research Center, College of Resource and Environment, Hubei Provincial Engineering Laboratory for New Fertilizers, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China

DOI: 10.26717/BJSTR.2020.24.004104

Abstract

Background: Molybdenum for plant growth is essential micronutrient wherever in enzyme catalysis it is required as catalytically active metal. Functional roles are fulfilled by molybdenum in enzyme systems in plants. Enzymes more than 50 Mo-containing are recognized, maximum of them are of bacterial origin, while a few Mo-enzymes are seen amongst eukaryotes. Five Mo-enzymes in plants, to this end are identified: AO, NR, SO, mARC and XDH which catalyze vital significant reactions in degradation of purine, synthesis of phytohormone, nitrogen assimilation and detoxification of sulfite.

Scope: The enzymes are significant regardless of having common structural elements, in the series of diverse chemical reactions those are being catalyzed, even though nearly all reactions are two electron oxidation reduction in this an atom of oxygen is transferred from or to the Mo. XDH family enzymes are described best mononuclear enzymes having molybdenum. This article will emphasis on computational approaches to those plant enzymes which requisite Mo as catalytic metal, focusing on their functions, key mechanisms, current prospects and future challenges.

Conclusion: Plants distress from deficiency of Mo is limited in growth and development, their leaves shows paleness, disorders in flower formation and ultimately withers. So, molybdenum nutrition for healthy growth and development of plant is key essential where it is being obligatory as a metal that is catalytically active in catalysis of enzymes (NR, SO, XDH, AO and mARC) that accomplishes functional roles in plants enzyme systems and known to participate in numerous redox reactions and results in proper plant growth and development while they have significant positions both in the redox biogeochemical cycles of N, S and C on earth and in the individual organism metabolism.Thus, prompt improvement in our understanding of Mo enzymes role and function in plants will help us that how it will be helpful for the proper plant functioning regarding their responses and metabolism.

Keywords: Molybdenum; Nitratereductse; Aldehyde Oxidase; Xanthine Dehydrogenase; Sulfite Oxidase; Mitochondrial Amidoximereductase; Inefficiency; Toxicity