Bilateral Geographic Atrophy of the Retina in Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome Associated with Cryptococcal Meningitis

Cryptococcal infections may occur in 5-10% of patients with AIDS and are associated with both direct and indirect ocular complications. It may result in meningitis and secondary ocular involvement such as chorioretinitis and endophthalmitis. We describe a rare case of extensive geographic atrophy of the retina in an HIV-patient presenting 10 years after hospitalization for cryptococcal meningitis.

hypertension and very rarely cryptococcal choroiditis [4]. We present a case of an HIV-positive patient with bilateral, permanent visual loss complicating cryptococcal meningitis.

Case Report
A 51-year-old Caucasian HIV-positive woman presented to our clinic complaining of decreased vision in both eyes for the last 10 years. She was diagnosed with HIV infection 20 years ago and was hospitalized for cryptococcal meningitis 10 years ago. She mentioned that, at that time, her CD4+ count was 40 cells/μL. Upon examination, visual acuity was counting fingers (CF) 2 ft in both eyes and intraocular pressure was 14 mm Hg bilaterally by noncontact tonometry. The anterior segment examination in both eyes was unremarkable, but fundoscopy revealed geographic atrophy and pigment deposition in the macula and the mid-periphery of the fundus of both eyes ( Figure 1). We performed an optical coherence tomography (OCT) which showed atrophy of the retinal layers in the macula ( Figure 2). We also performed fundus autofluorescence which showed retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) atrophy ( Figure   3) and fluorescein angiography which revealed multiple window defects in the macula and the mid-periphery of the fundus of both eyes corresponding to the retinochoroidal atrophy, with no sign of active disease (Figure 4). We established the diagnosis of geographic atrophy of the retina due to a past retinitis. The differential diagnosis of retinitis included VZV retinitis, HSV retinitis, CMV retinitis, Cryptococcal retinitis, ocular syphilis and Tb retinochoroiditis. We asked for a blood examination and a serology test for HSV-1 and HSV-2 (IgG, IgM), VZV (IgG, IgM), CMV (IgG, IgM), VDRL, FTA-ABS, RPR and Quantiferon-TB Gold test. We also performed a Mantoux tuberculin test and a Chest X-ray. All our results were negative for a past herpetic, cytomegalovirus, syphilitic or tuberculosis infection.
At the time of our examination, her CD4+ count was 430 cells/μL, she was in a pretty good general health and was under HAART. Due to the medical history of cryptococcal meningitis and the fact that the patient mentioned that she was first experiencing an alteration in visual acuity two months after her hospitalization 10 years ago, we assumed that Cryptococcus was the cause for the geographic atrophy of the retina.    We established the diagnosis of geographic atrophy of the retina due to a past retinitis. The differential diagnosis of retinitis included VZV retinitis, HSV retinitis, CMV retinitis, Cryptococcal retinitis, ocular syphilis and Tb retinochoroiditis. We asked for a blood exam and a serology test for HSV-1 and HSV-2 (IgG, IgM), VZV (IgG, IgM), CMV (IgG, IgM), VDRL, FTA-ABS, RPR and Quantiferon-TB Gold test. We also performed Mantoux test and a Chest X-ray.
All our results were negative for a past herpetic, cytomegalovirus, syphilitic or tuberculosis infection. At the time of our examination, her CD4 + count was 430 cells/μL, she was in a pretty good general health and was under HAART. Due to the medical history of cryptococcal meningitis and the fact that the patient mentioned that she was first experiencing an alteration in visual acuity two months after her hospitalization 10 years ago, we assumed that Cryptococcus was the cause for the geographic atrophy of the retina.

Discussion
Cryptococcus neoformans is a fungal pathogen that causes almost half a million deaths each year. Cryptococcal meningitis preferentially occurs in people with impaired cell-mediated immunity and is a major HIV-related opportunistic infection occurring when the CD4 + cell count falls below 100 cells/μL. With widespread implementation of successful antiretroviral therapy (HAART), the incidence of HIV-associated cryptococcosis has decreased significantly in most developed countries, although the incidence in other at-risk populations has not changed [3]. There have been found multiple yeast virulence factors of Cryptococcus neoformans. The 3 classical and most prominent factors include capsule formation, melanin pigment production, and thermotolerance [5].
Ocular signs and symptoms such as ocular palsies and papilloedema have been noted in a substantial proportion of cases of cryptococcal meningitis, even before the AIDS epidemic [6].
Several other ocular manifestations of cryptococcosis have been identified since then. Ocular involvement may occur directly with vasculitis and retinal exudate, such as in multifocal choroiditis, or more commonly indirectly with papilloedema and ocular motility dysfunction. Visual loss can also be the result of endophthalmitis due to extensive retinal disease with or without vitritis [7]. In some cases, visual loss may be owing to optic nerve infiltration by yeasts and cryptococcomas in the visual pathway, including the optic nerve, chiasm and tract. Irreversible blindness may be also due to vascular compromise of the optic nerve from intracranial hypertension [3]. There seem to be two patterns of visual loss in immunodeficient patients, one with the rapid onset of visual loss with limited effective treatment options, and the other with gradual visual deterioration. This difference probably relies on the different etiologic mechanisms. The rapid onset of vision loss (3 days) is thought to result from direct infiltration of the optic nerve or adhesive or inflammatory arachnoiditis [8,9], while visual loss over a period of more than four weeks has been attributed more commonly to long term intracranial hypertension [9].
Our patient presented 10 years after her visual acuity started to decline, limiting our capability for a certain diagnosis. She suffered permanent, bilateral visual loss due to bilateral geographic atrophy.
There were found extensive, multiple foci of retinal atrophy both in the macula and the periphery of the fundus of both eyes indicating a past retinal infection. There was no sign of reactivation of the disease. Serological tests were negative for many possible causative factors such as herpetic infection. Taking into consideration her past medical history, we regarded this to be a case of past cryptococcal chorioretinitis. Unfortunately, there was no therapeutic regimen to be done by the time of presentation to our clinic.